ASC 606 Implementation: Steps, Challenges, and Solutions

December 10, 2024
Jason Berwanger
Accounting

Understand ASC 606 and its impact on revenue recognition. Learn practical steps for implementation and overcoming common challenges. Read more now!

ASC 606 Implementation: Steps, Challenges, and Solutions

In the world of business, clarity is king. When it comes to your financials, that clarity starts with a solid understanding of ASC 606. This revenue recognition standard, while often viewed as a compliance hurdle, can actually be a powerful tool for improving your financial operations. By implementing ASC 606 effectively, you can gain a clearer picture of your revenue streams, make more informed decisions, and build stronger relationships with investors and stakeholders.

Login Button

Key Takeaways

  • ASC 606 impacts how you report revenue: No matter your industry, understanding the five steps of implementation – identifying the contract, pinpointing obligations, determining the price, allocating it, and recognizing revenue – is crucial for accurate financial reporting.
  • Technology simplifies ASC 606 compliance: Streamline the process with automated solutions that integrate with your existing systems. This saves time, reduces errors, and provides a clearer picture of your financial performance.
  • ASC 606 is more than a checklist: Use it as an opportunity to improve your business. By understanding the standard, you can enhance transparency, make better decisions, and streamline operations for long-term success.

What is ASC 606?

ASC 606 is a revenue recognition standard that affects businesses across industries. It provides a consistent framework for recognizing revenue, which helps ensure financial statements are comparable and transparent.

Think of it this way: ASC 606 creates a standardized approach for businesses to track and report the money they make from selling products or services. This standard helps prevent inconsistencies in how revenue is reported, making it easier for investors and stakeholders to understand a company's financial performance.

ASC 606 impacts any business that engages with customers to provide goods or services. The core principle of ASC 606 is recognizing revenue when goods or services are transferred to customers, reflecting the expected payment in return.

In simpler terms, imagine you own a bakery. ASC 606 guides you on how to record the sale of a cake: you recognize the revenue when the cake is handed to the customer, not when they place the order or eventually pay for it.

ASC 606 falls under the Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) for GAAP accounting. It requires businesses to provide more detailed disclosures about their revenue recognition practices. This increased transparency helps investors and analysts make more informed decisions.

Implement ASC 606 in 5 Steps

Think of these five steps as the pillars of ASC 606 compliance. Each one is crucial for accurate revenue reporting.

Step 1: Identify the Contract

First things first: you need a contract. This is any agreement between your business and a customer that creates legally enforceable rights and obligations. Seems straightforward, but nailing down the specifics of each customer contract is essential for the rest of the process.

Step 2: Pinpoint Performance Obligations

Next, identify the specific promises you make to your customer within the contract. These are your performance obligations — the distinct goods or services you’ve agreed to deliver. Clearly defining these obligations from the get-go makes it much easier to track whether (and when) you’ve fulfilled your end of the bargain.

Step 3: Determine the Transaction Price

This step is all about figuring out how much your customer will pay in exchange for those goods or services. It’s not always as simple as looking at the sticker price. You’ll need to factor in things like variable considerations (think: bonuses or discounts) and any rebates.

Step 4: Allocate the Transaction Price

Now that you know the total transaction price, it’s time to divvy it up. Allocate the price across each performance obligation you identified in Step 2. This means figuring out the standalone selling price of each individual good or service included in the contract.

Step 5: Recognize Revenue

This is the heart of ASC 606. Once you’ve completed the previous steps, you can recognize revenue as you satisfy each performance obligation. This could happen at a specific point in time (like when you deliver a product) or over a period of time (like with a subscription service). Understanding the right time to recognize revenue is key for compliance.

Which Industries Does ASC 606 Affect Most?

While ASC 606 impacts any business that enters into contracts with customers, certain industries feel its effects more profoundly. Let's explore why:

Technology Sector

The technology sector often grapples with complex revenue models, particularly software companies that offer subscriptions, licenses, and services. ASC 606's guidelines bring significant changes to how these companies recognize revenue, especially when bundling products and services.

Manufacturing

Manufacturers frequently engage in long-term contracts with customers, often involving milestone payments and warranties. ASC 606's emphasis on recognizing revenue as control of a product or service transfers impacts how manufacturers account for these contracts.

Construction

The construction industry, with its project-based nature and long-term contracts, faces unique challenges. Construction companies must carefully analyze their contracts to determine the proper timing for revenue recognition, especially when dealing with change orders and variable consideration.

Telecommunications

Telecommunications companies often bundle services and offer promotional deals, creating complexities in revenue recognition. ASC 606's focus on identifying separate performance obligations within contracts requires telecom providers to reassess their accounting for bundled offerings.

Common ASC 606 Implementation Challenges

Let's be real, implementing a new accounting standard like ASC 606 is rarely easy. Businesses often face hurdles in several key areas. Let's break down these common challenges:

Data Collection and Management

ASC 606 is all about your contracts. The implementation is smoothest when you can easily trace revenue back to the specific contract it originated from. Sounds simple enough, right? But many companies haven't always tracked their revenue this way. You might be used to organizing things by product line or customer. As a result, shifting all that historical data to align with ASC 606 can turn into a massive headache. Think data reformatting, reconciliation – the works.

Contract Identification and Analysis

Under ASC 606, you're required to estimate something called "variable consideration" when figuring out the transaction price. Basically, this means factoring in things like discounts or bonuses that might change the final amount. To do this accurately, you need rock-solid data. But getting that "accurate and complete data" to figure out things like standalone selling prices and potential variable consideration? That's where many companies hit a snag.

Update Systems and Processes

Here's the thing: ASC 606 often requires businesses to make significant changes to their financial systems and processes. Many companies find themselves needing to upgrade their accounting software or even overhaul their entire revenue recognition process. And because this standard is relatively new, there's a learning curve for everyone involved – businesses, auditors, and regulators alike. This often leads to mistakes that could be avoided with the right systems and processes in place.

Variable Consideration Complexities

Remember "variable consideration"? It can get even trickier. ASC 606 wants you to look closely at customer options and figure out if those options actually give the customer a special right. For example, does a customer loyalty program impact your revenue recognition? This analysis can be complex, especially when dealing with contracts that have a lot of moving parts.

Internal Control and Disclosure Requirements

ASC 606 doesn't just impact how you recognize revenue – it also comes with stricter requirements for your internal controls and disclosures. You need to make sure your internal controls are strong enough to support the new revenue recognition process. Plus, you'll need to provide more detailed disclosures in your financial statements. It's easy to overlook these areas while you're busy with the technical aspects of implementation, but neglecting them can create risks down the line.

Achieve ASC 606 Compliance

Successfully transitioning to and maintaining compliance with ASC 606 requires a strategic approach. Here's a breakdown to guide your efforts:

Form a Dedicated Implementation Team

Don't underestimate the importance of a dedicated team for ASC 606 implementation. As highlighted by TGG Accounting, this process provides a great opportunity to evaluate your current revenue system and pinpoint any redundancies within your accounting department. This team will act as the central point of contact for all things ASC 606, ensuring a smoother transition.

Develop a Comprehensive Implementation Plan

A well-structured implementation plan is key. Performio outlines five steps involved in the new revenue recognition process: identifying the contract, pinpointing performance obligations, determining the transaction price, allocating the price, and recognizing revenue. Your plan should detail each step, assign responsibilities, and establish clear timelines.

Educate Stakeholders Across the Organization

ASC 606 impacts various departments, not just accounting. RevenueHub recommends educating stakeholders across your organization about the standard, its implications, and their roles in ensuring compliance. This fosters a collaborative approach and minimizes misunderstandings down the line.

Review and Update Internal Controls

With the implementation of ASC 606, auditors will be paying close attention to your internal control over financial reporting (ICFR). Baker Tilly emphasizes the importance of strong ICFR in connection with annual audits, especially during the initial year of ASC 606 implementation. Review your existing internal controls and update them to align with the new standard.

Address Contract Complexities

The ease of ASC 606 implementation often hinges on the clarity of your contracts. RevenueHub points out that a contract-driven model works best when revenue can be easily traced back to its corresponding contract. Identify and address any complexities within your contracts early on to prevent roadblocks during implementation.

Use Technology for ASC 606 Implementation

Let's be real, tackling ASC 606 compliance without the right tools can feel like you're navigating a maze in the dark. Thankfully, technology can be a game-changer. By integrating the right solutions, you can streamline the entire revenue recognition process.

Automated Revenue Recognition Solutions

Think of automated revenue recognition software as your co-pilot for ASC 606. These solutions are designed to simplify complex accounting procedures. They can automate tasks such as:

  • Accrual accounting
  • Revenue recognition calculations
  • Financial reporting

This not only saves you time and reduces the risk of errors but also provides a clearer, more accurate view of your financial performance. As TGG Accounting points out, implementing ASC 606 presents a prime opportunity to identify and eliminate redundant tasks within your accounting department, and automation is key to achieving this.

Integrate with Existing Financial Systems

Don't worry, adopting new technology doesn't mean overhauling your entire financial infrastructure. Look for solutions that seamlessly integrate with your existing accounting software, ERPs, and CRMs. This interconnectivity ensures a smooth flow of data between systems, minimizing manual data entry and reducing the chance of discrepancies.

HubiFi specializes in providing these types of integrations, helping you create a unified financial ecosystem.

Data Analytics and Reporting Tools

Data is at the heart of ASC 606 compliance. You need to be able to easily access, analyze, and report on revenue-related data. Robust data analytics and reporting tools can help you:

  • Track key performance indicators (KPIs)
  • Generate custom reports
  • Gain insights into revenue trends

This data-driven approach not only simplifies compliance but also empowers you to make more informed business decisions. Having accurate and complete data is crucial for developing and updating estimates, especially when determining the standalone selling price of performance obligations.

Make Key Judgments During ASC 606 Implementation

Successfully adopting ASC 606 is more than just checking boxes. It requires companies to make thoughtful judgments that directly impact revenue recognition. Let's break down some of these key judgment areas:

Identify Distinct Performance Obligations

First, you need to identify distinct performance obligations within your contracts. This means figuring out if the goods or services you're providing are distinct enough to stand on their own and if they're clearly separate from other promises outlined in the contract.

For example, imagine you're selling a software package that includes implementation services. Are those services truly distinct from the software itself? Or are they so intertwined that they should be considered a single performance obligation? Your answer directly impacts how you recognize revenue.

Estimate Variable Consideration

Next, consider variable consideration. This refers to any part of the transaction price that might change, such as discounts, rebates, or performance bonuses. ASC 606 requires you to estimate this variable consideration when determining the total transaction price.

The key is to be realistic. You need to estimate to a point where you're confident a significant portion of the recognized revenue won't need to be reversed later. This involves analyzing historical data, market conditions, and the specific terms of each contract.

Determine Standalone Selling Prices

ASC 606 also requires you to figure out the standalone selling price (SSP) for each distinct performance obligation. Essentially, what would customers pay for each item or service if you sold it separately?

There are a few different methods for determining SSP, including:

  • Adjusted market assessment approach: Looking at what competitors charge for similar items.
  • Expected cost plus a margin approach: Calculating the cost of providing the good or service and adding a reasonable profit margin.
  • Residual approach: This is used when the SSP is difficult to determine directly. You subtract the SSPs of other performance obligations in the contract from the total transaction price.

Choosing the right method depends on the nature of your business and the availability of reliable data.

Choose Methods for Measuring Progress

Finally, you'll need to decide how you'll measure progress toward fulfilling each performance obligation. This helps determine when to recognize revenue—either over time or at a single point in time.

There are two primary methods:

  • Output methods: These measure progress based on the results achieved. For example, if your company is building a house, you might recognize revenue based on the percentage of completion.
  • Input methods: These measure progress based on the resources used. For example, you might recognize revenue for a consulting project based on the number of hours worked.

Selecting the appropriate method depends on the nature of the performance obligation and how you track your work.

Address Common ASC 606 Misconceptions

Let's clear the air about a few common misconceptions surrounding ASC 606. Many companies stumble during implementation because they underestimate the time, resources, and strategic planning involved.

It's Not Just a Compliance Exercise

It's easy to view ASC 606 as just another box to check for compliance. Forward-thinking companies, however, realize that ASC 606 implementation presents a valuable opportunity to streamline financial operations. One Fortune 100 company found that approaching ASC 606 as a chance to improve efficiency and accuracy, rather than a mere compliance hurdle, led to the identification of task redundancy within their accounting department.

Transition Is More Complex Than Expected

Don't underestimate the intricacies of transitioning to ASC 606. Accurately estimating variable consideration, a key component of the standard, often poses a significant challenge. Many companies struggle to gather the accurate and complete data needed to determine the transaction price, impacting the standalone selling price of performance obligations.

Impact on Financial Reporting and KPIs

Beyond the immediate changes to revenue recognition, ASC 606 has a ripple effect on financial reporting and key performance indicators (KPIs). By standardizing revenue recognition practices, ASC 606 promotes transparency and makes it easier to compare financial statements across different companies and industries. This enhanced transparency fosters trust and confidence among stakeholders who rely on accurate and reliable financial information.

Access ASC 606 Training and Resources

Staying informed and getting properly trained on the revenue recognition standard is crucial for accurate implementation. Here are some avenues to consider:

Overview of the Revenue Recognition Standard

ASC 606 provides a comprehensive framework for recognizing revenue from customer contracts. Unlike previous standards that focused on risks and rewards, ASC 606 emphasizes the transfer of control. This shift requires companies to carefully evaluate their contracts to determine the appropriate timing and amount of revenue to recognize. To understand this framework better, explore KPMG’s breakdown of revenue from contracts with customers.

Industry-Specific Insights and Guidance

It’s important to remember that ASC 606 can significantly impact revenue recognition practices differently across industries. Companies should seek out industry-specific guidance and examples to effectively navigate the standard's complexities. For companies transitioning to the new standard, KPMG offers resources on revenue recognition accounting.

Practical Implementation Workshops

Organizations transitioning to ASC 606 often find value in practical implementation workshops. These workshops use real-world examples and experiences to provide actionable insights. Many workshops draw upon resources from organizations like the AICPA Revenue Recognition Working Groups and FASB TRG. To find a workshop, take a look at the AICPA's revenue recognition training courses.

Ongoing Support and Updates

Don't think of ASC 606 implementation as a one-and-done deal. Continuous education and updates are essential. Resources like e-books and insights from accounting firms can help your organization stay informed about the latest changes and best practices in revenue recognition. For example, Baker Tilly offers helpful insights for construction contractors navigating ASC 606.

Reap Long-Term Benefits of ASC 606

Sure, transitioning to ASC 606 might feel like a heavy lift at first, but sticking with it pays off. Once you're compliant, you'll find it's more than just checking a box—it's about unlocking real, lasting advantages for your business. Let's explore some of the long-term wins:

Enhanced Financial Transparency

ASC 606 pushes for consistency. By standardizing how companies recognize revenue, it makes financial statements easier to understand, both internally and for external stakeholders. This improved transparency allows investors and analysts to compare your performance with competitors on a more level playing field.

Improve Decision-Making Capabilities

Implementing ASC 606 often acts as a catalyst for companies to take a hard look at their revenue cycle. This process can uncover opportunities to streamline operations and eliminate redundancies, ultimately leading to smarter, data-driven decisions.

Streamline Auditing Processes

While getting ready for ASC 606 requires a close review of your internal controls over financial reporting (ICFR), this prep work ultimately makes audits smoother. With stronger controls and clearer documentation, you'll be well-prepared for auditor scrutiny and reduce the risk of surprises.

Continuous Monitoring and Updates

ASC 606 isn't a "set it and forget it" situation. Staying compliant requires ongoing monitoring and adjustments as your business evolves or new accounting standards emerge. This continuous process, while requiring diligence, helps you stay agile and adapt to changes in the regulatory landscape.

Related Articles

Login Button

Frequently Asked Questions About ASC 606

What happens if my business doesn't comply with ASC 606?

Failing to comply with ASC 606 can have serious consequences. Your financial statements could be considered inaccurate or misleading, potentially leading to regulatory penalties, restatements of financials, and damage to your company's reputation. It's also important to remember that investors and lenders rely on accurate financial information to make decisions. Non-compliance can make it harder to secure funding or attract investors.

How can automated solutions help with some of the judgment calls required by ASC 606?

While automated solutions can't replace human judgment entirely, they can provide valuable support. For example, they can help you analyze large volumes of contract data to identify distinct performance obligations, automate complex calculations for variable consideration, and track progress toward satisfying performance obligations. This frees up your team to focus on areas that require more nuanced decision-making.

Our business primarily uses short-term contracts. Is ASC 606 still relevant for us?

Even if your business primarily operates on short-term contracts, ASC 606 still applies. The standard's principles for recognizing revenue apply to all customer contracts, regardless of their duration. While the implementation might be less complex for businesses with straightforward contracts, it's still crucial to understand the standard's requirements and ensure your revenue recognition practices align with them.

What are some practical examples of how ASC 606 impacts revenue recognition for online businesses?

Let's say you run a subscription box service. ASC 606 requires you to identify each distinct good or service included in the subscription box and allocate a portion of the total transaction price to each one. You'll also need to determine the appropriate point in time to recognize revenue for each element. For example, you might recognize revenue for a physical product when it's shipped, while revenue for a digital product or service might be recognized over the subscription period.

What are the first steps we should take to prepare for ASC 606 implementation?

Start by assembling a dedicated team with representatives from different departments, including finance, accounting, sales, and legal. This team will be responsible for overseeing the implementation process. Next, conduct a thorough review of your existing contracts and revenue recognition policies to identify any gaps or areas that need to be updated. Finally, consider investing in technology solutions that can help streamline the implementation process and ensure ongoing compliance.

Jason Berwanger

Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups

Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.

Book a demo

Learn how we cut accounting close timelines by 75% and identified 6% of revenue margin erosion opportunities for one of the fastest growing companies.

Get Started