Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Get a Demo
See your data in HubiFi < 2 days
Learn how dunning payments can help recover lost revenue and maintain customer relationships with this practical guide.
Running a subscription-based business or regularly dealing with recurring invoices? Then you know the frustration of failed payments. Chasing down overdue invoices can be a major drain on your time and resources. But what if there was a way to recover that lost revenue without alienating your customers? That's where dunning payments comes in. Dunning is a strategic approach to managing late payments, and it's more than just sending angry emails. It's about building a system that recovers revenue while preserving valuable customer relationships. In this guide, we'll explore the ins and outs of dunning payments, from understanding its core purpose to implementing best practices and leveraging technology for a seamless, customer-centric approach.
Dunning management is how businesses handle failed payments, especially recurring credit card payments for subscription services. Think of it as a structured approach to recovering lost revenue due to declined payments. Over time, dunning has shifted from aggressive debt collection tactics to a more customer-centric process. The focus now is on retaining customers while also recouping lost revenue.
At its core, dunning is about politely reminding customers about overdue payments. It's a critical process for any business that relies on recurring revenue. Effective dunning helps maintain healthy cash flow, minimize bad debt (payments you're unlikely to receive), and, importantly, preserve positive customer relationships. Stripe explains dunning as a way to maintain healthy cash flow and keep good customer relationships. It involves a series of communications, starting with gentle reminders and gradually becoming more assertive if needed. The ultimate goal is to get those invoices paid while keeping your customers happy.
Failed payments can significantly impact your bottom line. Subscription businesses, for example, can lose around 9% of their annual revenue due to involuntary churn caused by failed payments. This is a substantial chunk of change, highlighting the need for a robust dunning strategy. Chargebee's research shows that about one in four transactions that go through dunning are recovered. However, the good news is that with a well-executed dunning process, you can recover a substantial portion of these failed payments. This recovered revenue improves your cash flow, making financial planning and forecasting more predictable. Successfully recovering payments through dunning also reduces the amount of money lost due to unpaid invoices, directly impacting your profitability. This improved financial stability allows for better resource allocation and strategic decision-making. For more insights on optimizing your financial operations, explore our blog for valuable resources and learn more about HubiFi's integrations. You can also schedule a demo to see how HubiFi can help streamline your revenue recognition process and view our pricing information.
This section explores how smart dunning management is crucial for healthy revenue and strong customer relationships.
Dunning is about recovering revenue that would otherwise be lost due to failed payments. For subscription businesses, these failed payments, often from expired or invalid credit cards, are a major source of involuntary customer churn. Studies show that up to half of all churn can be attributed to involuntary reasons. Even a small 1% increase in churn can cause a significant drop in revenue—sometimes 10% or more. Failed payments represent a real drain on annual income, with some businesses losing nearly 9% of their yearly earnings to this issue. A solid dunning process, with proactive reminders and follow-ups, is key to plugging this leak and maintaining consistent cash flow.
While dunning might seem purely financial, it has a big impact on customer relationships. Done right, it can actually improve customer loyalty. It's not just about collecting overdue payments; it's about showing customers you value them and want to help them maintain access to your services. Effective dunning relies on clear communication and empathy. It recognizes that customers might have valid reasons for late payments. By approaching these situations with understanding and offering solutions, you can turn a potentially negative interaction into a chance to build trust and reinforce a positive brand image. This approach minimizes preventable churn and creates stronger, more loyal customer relationships.
Dunning is how businesses encourage customers to pay overdue invoices. It’s a series of communications that start as gentle nudges and become more persistent when necessary. A well-designed dunning process is key for maintaining healthy cash flow and strong customer relationships. Let's break down the typical stages:
The first stage of dunning focuses on friendly reminders. Often, a simple oversight is the reason for a late payment. An initial email or text a few days before the due date can be helpful. If the invoice remains unpaid after the due date, a second, slightly more direct communication follows. This might be an automated email or a personalized message referencing the overdue invoice and payment terms. These early communications aim to resolve the issue quickly and painlessly. Regular follow-ups like these prevent small oversights from becoming bigger problems. Actively pursuing overdue payments often leads to higher collections and improved cash flow.
If initial reminders don’t prompt payment, the dunning process moves into more assertive territory. This stage involves more frequent and direct communication. A series of emails or letters clearly stating the outstanding amount, due date, and potential late fees is common practice. Phone calls can also be effective at this stage, allowing for direct conversation and a chance to understand any payment roadblocks the customer might be experiencing. This personal touch can sometimes make all the difference. The goal here is to get the customer’s attention and emphasize the importance of settling the outstanding balance. Learn more about how HubiFi can help automate this process.
When all previous attempts fail, the dunning process enters its final stage. This might involve handing the account over to a collections agency), sending a formal notification of potential legal action, or, as a last resort, pursuing litigation. While sometimes necessary, these actions should be handled carefully. Dunning, especially at this stage, can strain customer relationships. It’s important to balance the need to recover revenue with the desire to maintain a positive brand image. Consider the long-term impact on customer retention before taking drastic measures. A clear dunning policy helps your team manage this process effectively and maintain professionalism. For more insights on balancing revenue recovery and customer relationships, explore our resources on the HubiFi blog.
Crafting a robust dunning strategy is crucial for maintaining healthy cash flow and preserving customer relationships. It's a balancing act, requiring a delicate blend of persistence and empathy. Here’s how to strike that balance:
When contacting customers about overdue payments, clarity is paramount. Use straightforward language, explaining the reason for the communication and outlining the steps they need to take. Avoid jargon or technical terms that might confuse them. Instead, opt for a friendly, empathetic tone that acknowledges the possibility of an oversight. For example, a simple phrase like, "We noticed your recent payment didn't go through," is more approachable than a stern demand. This customer-centric approach fosters understanding and reinforces a respectful relationship, even during a potentially sensitive conversation. Remember, dunning is about politely reminding customers, not aggressively demanding payment, as Stripe explains.
Timing and frequency are critical components of an effective dunning strategy. A well-timed reminder can prevent late payments altogether. Start with gentle nudges shortly after a payment is missed, then gradually increase the frequency and urgency of your communications. Regular reminders are key to higher collections. However, bombarding customers with excessive notifications can be counterproductive, leading to frustration and potentially damaging your customer relationships. Finding the right balance is essential. Consider automating this process to save time and ensure consistency. Automating your dunning process frees up your team to focus on other important tasks.
A one-size-fits-all approach rarely works in dunning. Personalizing your communication can significantly improve your success rate. Tailor your messages to each customer's situation, referencing specific invoice details or past payment history. This demonstrates that you value their business and aren't simply sending generic reminders. Personalizing your dunning process shows you’re paying attention. Furthermore, leverage multiple communication channels to reach your customers effectively. While email is a standard method, consider incorporating SMS messages, phone calls, or even traditional mail, especially for persistent overdue accounts. Combining different channels increases your chances of getting a response and ultimately securing payment.
Dunning can be a tedious process, but it doesn’t have to be. Technology can automate many steps, freeing up your team to focus on other essential tasks. This not only saves time but also reduces errors and improves overall efficiency.
Dunning automation software can handle various aspects of the process, from sending initial reminders to escalating collection efforts. When a payment fails, the system can automatically:
Using automated tools significantly improves the efficiency and effectiveness of your dunning process, leading to better cash flow management and fewer late payments. Think of it as a tireless virtual assistant dedicated to keeping your revenue cycle on track. This allows your team to focus on strategic initiatives and customer relationship building.
Data analytics and AI can take your dunning process to the next level. By analyzing historical data, you can identify patterns and trends in payment behavior. This information helps you decide the best time and method to contact customers, personalize your communication, and predict the likelihood of successful payment. Data-driven insights allow you to refine your strategies and optimize the entire dunning process for maximum effectiveness. You can even use A/B testing to experiment with different messaging and timing to see what resonates best with your customers. Tracking your results and making data-backed changes is key to continuous improvement. For example, you might find that sending reminders on Tuesdays at 10 AM yields the highest response rate.
For a truly seamless workflow, integrate your dunning software with your existing accounting software, CRM, and other business systems. This integration ensures that all your data is synced and up to date, eliminating manual data entry and reducing the risk of errors. A centralized system provides a comprehensive view of your customer's payment history and interactions, enabling you to make informed decisions and personalize your dunning approach. Dunning software streamlines the entire process, saving you time and allowing you to focus on other critical aspects of your business. For example, integrating with your CRM can provide valuable context about the customer, allowing you to tailor your communication and offer personalized solutions. This personalized approach can improve customer satisfaction and increase the likelihood of recovering payments.
Effective dunning management requires a strategic approach. Here are some best practices to maximize recovery and maintain positive customer relationships:
From the outset, establish crystal-clear payment terms with your customers. This includes specifying due dates, accepted payment methods, and any consequences of late or non-payment, such as late fees or suspended service. Transparency upfront sets expectations and reduces misunderstandings. When customers know exactly what’s expected, they’re more likely to pay on time. Clearly outlining these terms in your contracts or service agreements prevents disputes and makes the dunning process smoother. Consider offering a grace period before initiating dunning to account for occasional oversights.
Not all customers have the same financial circumstances. Offering flexible payment options can significantly improve customer satisfaction and reduce the need for extensive dunning. Consider allowing customers to choose from different payment plans, such as installments or recurring subscriptions tailored to their budgets. Providing various payment methods, like credit cards, debit cards, or digital wallets, also caters to diverse preferences. This flexibility makes it easier for customers to manage their payments, reducing the likelihood of failed transactions and the need for dunning.
Failed payments happen. Instead of immediately sending a dunning notice, implement smart retry logic in your payment system. This involves automatically retrying failed payments at strategic intervals. For example, you might retry a failed card transaction a few days later, as the issue might be a temporary lack of funds. Smart retry logic increases the chances of successful transactions without overwhelming the customer with constant notifications. This automated approach can recover a significant portion of potentially lost revenue before manual intervention is even necessary. You can also incorporate account updater services to automatically refresh expired or outdated payment information.
Dunning management isn’t a set-it-and-forget-it task. Regularly review and refine your dunning process based on data and customer feedback. Track key metrics like recovery rates, customer churn, and the effectiveness of different communication strategies. Analyze this data to identify areas for improvement. Perhaps a certain type of reminder email performs better than others, or maybe adjusting the timing or frequency of your notifications yields better results. By continuously analyzing and adapting your approach, you can optimize your dunning process for maximum effectiveness and minimize any negative impact on customer relationships. Consider A/B testing different dunning strategies to see what resonates best with your customer base. Gathering customer feedback through surveys or feedback forms can provide valuable insights into how to make the dunning process less disruptive.
Once you’ve implemented your dunning process, how do you know if it’s working? Tracking key metrics helps you understand the effectiveness of your dunning strategy and identify areas for improvement. This allows you to fine-tune your approach and maximize revenue recovery while minimizing customer churn.
Your dunning recovery rate is the percentage of failed payments you successfully collect. A healthy recovery rate is a strong indicator of a well-executed dunning process, given that one in four transactions that go through dunning are typically recovered. Chargebee explains why this is a critical metric for SaaS businesses. Tracking the time it takes to recover a payment is also crucial. A shorter recovery time translates to faster revenue recognition and improved cash flow. Analyze your recovery rate and time to identify trends and optimize the timing and frequency of your dunning communications.
Dunning, while essential for revenue recovery, can sometimes contribute to customer churn if not handled carefully. Involuntary churn due to failed payments can account for a significant portion—up to half—of your total churn. Even a slight uptick in churn, as little as 1%, can significantly impact your bottom line, potentially leading to a revenue decrease of 10% or more. Closely monitor your churn rate alongside your dunning efforts to understand the relationship between the two. This will help you refine your dunning strategy to minimize its impact on customer retention. For a deeper dive into this relationship, check out more insights from Chargebee.
Dunning directly impacts your business's financial health. Failed payments can lead to significant revenue loss, with subscription businesses losing approximately 9% of their yearly income from this issue alone. Stripe highlights the importance of timely payments for the smooth operation of any business. By implementing an effective dunning process, you can ensure timely payments, improve your cash flow, and maintain a healthy financial outlook. Regularly review your financial statements to assess the impact of your dunning strategy on your overall financial performance. To streamline your financial operations, consider exploring HubiFi's automated revenue recognition solutions.
Successfully recovering revenue is essential, but not at the expense of your customer relationships. It's a delicate balancing act. This section focuses on how to implement dunning practices that bring in the money while keeping your customers happy.
Dunning has a bit of a bad rap. Customers often find it intrusive, and businesses can struggle with uncooperative clients. However, if you handle overdue payments well, you can actually improve customer loyalty. Think of dunning as an opportunity to demonstrate excellent customer service, not as a confrontational process. Effective dunning isn’t just about collecting money; it’s about maintaining positive customer relationships and reducing preventable churn, as Chargebee points out. By communicating clearly and respectfully, you show customers you value them, even when addressing late payments. This approach can strengthen your brand image and encourage repeat business. Frame your dunning communications as helpful reminders rather than aggressive demands. This subtle shift in tone can make a big difference in how your messages are received.
Sometimes, it makes more sense to prioritize customer retention over immediate payment collection. Invoiced suggests leading with empathy. Understand that customers may have legitimate reasons for late payments. Communicate with compassion and gradually increase the firmness of your requests. If a long-term, high-value customer experiences a temporary financial setback, working with them to create a flexible payment plan might be more beneficial in the long run than strict adherence to your standard dunning process. This demonstrates flexibility and understanding, which can foster stronger customer loyalty. Consider offering alternative payment options or temporarily suspending their service while they get back on track. Remember, acquiring new customers is often more expensive than retaining existing ones. A little flexibility can go a long way in preserving valuable customer relationships. For more insights on streamlining your processes, explore Stripe's guide on dunning, which offers valuable advice on using software and data to optimize your approach and find the right balance between revenue recovery and customer satisfaction. At HubiFi, we understand the importance of this balance. Schedule a demo to see how our automated revenue recognition solutions can help you optimize your dunning process while maintaining positive customer relationships.
Dunning might seem straightforward, but it presents unique challenges. Successfully managing these hurdles is key to protecting your revenue and your customer relationships. Let's break down some common roadblocks and how to address them.
Legal compliance is paramount in dunning. Regulations like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) dictate how you can communicate with customers about outstanding payments. Make sure your dunning process adheres to all applicable federal and state laws. This includes being transparent about the debt, avoiding harassment, and respecting consumer rights. Non-compliance can lead to legal trouble and damage your brand's reputation. Review the FDCPA guidelines to ensure your practices are compliant.
Not all outstanding payments are due to intentional late payments. Customers might have legitimate reasons for non-payment, such as billing errors, faulty products, or financial hardship. Approach these situations with empathy. Listen to their concerns and investigate their claims thoroughly. A friendly and professional tone can go a long way in resolving disputes amicably. If a genuine error has occurred, rectify it promptly and apologize for the inconvenience. Offering flexible payment options, like installments or temporary suspensions, can help retain customers facing temporary difficulties.
Dunning can be time-consuming, especially for businesses with high transaction volumes. Manually tracking invoices, sending reminders, and following up on payments can quickly overwhelm your team. This is where automation comes in. Investing in dunning software can streamline the entire process. Automated systems can send timely reminders, escalate actions based on pre-defined rules, and even generate reports on dunning performance. This frees up your staff to focus on more strategic tasks, like building customer relationships and improving your product offerings. Explore different software options and choose one that integrates seamlessly with your existing accounting and CRM systems. Consider scheduling a data consultation with HubiFi to discuss how we can help automate your revenue recovery process.
What is the difference between dunning and debt collection?
While both involve pursuing overdue payments, dunning typically refers to the initial stages of recovering payments for recurring services like subscriptions, focusing on reminders and resolving unintentional late payments. Debt collection, on the other hand, usually involves more aggressive tactics for recovering larger, older outstanding debts, often after other attempts have failed. Dunning aims to retain customers while recovering revenue, whereas debt collection is primarily focused on recovering the debt, sometimes with less emphasis on the customer relationship.
How can I calculate my dunning recovery rate?
Your dunning recovery rate is the percentage of failed payments you successfully recover. Calculate it by dividing the total value of recovered payments during a specific period by the total value of failed payments during the same period, then multiply by 100. For example, if you recovered $5,000 from $20,000 in failed payments, your recovery rate is 25%.
What are some common reasons for failed payments?
Failed payments can occur for various reasons, including insufficient funds, expired credit cards, incorrect card details, or technical issues with the payment gateway. Sometimes, customers might also cancel their cards without updating their payment information with you. Proactive communication and offering multiple payment options can help mitigate some of these issues.
Is dunning regulated by any laws?
Yes, dunning practices are subject to regulations like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) in the United States. These regulations aim to protect consumers from unfair or abusive debt collection practices. Make sure your dunning process adheres to these regulations to avoid legal issues and maintain a positive brand image.
What's the best way to choose dunning software for my business?
The best dunning software for your business depends on your specific needs and budget. Consider factors like the size of your business, the volume of transactions you process, and the level of automation you require. Look for software that integrates seamlessly with your existing systems, offers flexible communication options, and provides robust reporting and analytics features. Many dunning software solutions offer free trials or demos, allowing you to test the software before committing to a purchase.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Copyright © 2025 HubiFi | All rights reserved.
